Search This Blog

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

CIVILIAN COURT-MARTIAL DEFENSE LAWYER: TWO MILITARY OFFICERS REPRESENTED BY ATTORNEY RICHARD V. STEVENS RETAINED IN MILITARY AFTER FACING INVOLUNTARY ADMINISTRATIVE DISCHARGE BOARD HEARING CASES

 

Military Defense Lawyer (Former JAG Attorney) News:

Recently, in two separate, unrelated cases, military officers defended by attorney Richard V. Stevens (Military Defense Law Offices of Richard V. Stevens, P.C.) were retained in the military after facing involuntary administrative discharge board cases.        

In the military justice system, a military member can face involuntary administrative discharge action (“getting kicked out”) for a variety of reasons.  These reasons can include alleged misconduct or failing military standards.  Under certain circumstances, the military member is entitled to an administrative discharge board hearing – either because of their time in service, the military is seeking an Under Other Than Honorable Conditions discharge, or both. 

These administrative discharge board hearings are similar to trials.  They are litigated hearings.  Evidence and witness testimony is presented.  There are opening statements and closing arguments.  The board members then deliberate and return their decision.  The arguments in a discharge board hearing are just about retention in the military versus conviction in a military court-martial trial. 

Involuntary administrative discharge board hearings in the military are called by different names, in different branches, and based on different ranks.  This can include:  “ADSEP”  “Board of Inquiry (BOI)”  “Show Cause Board”  “Officer Elimination Action.”

Both of the officer clients in these two cases faced fully litigated involuntary administrative discharge board hearings.  In these hearings, there are potentially three questions.  The first question is whether there is a basis for discharge?  This means:  did the respondent do what he/she is accused of?  If, despite the lower burden of proof (preponderance of the evidence) the board members determine there is no basis, the respondent is retained in the military service and the members do not go on to the other questions.

If the board hearing members determine there is a basis for discharge, they then move to question #2, which is – Even if there is a basis for discharge, should the respondent be discharged?  If the board determines that the answer to this second question is “no, the respondent should not be discharged, he/she should be retained” then they do not move to question #3.  If, on the other hand, the board members determine that they believe the respondent should be discharged, then they move to question #3. 

Question #3 is – What should be the characterization of discharge?  Honorable?  General, Under Honorable Conditions?  Or, Under Other Than Honorable Conditions?

What the defense hopes in these board hearings is to win on question #1, and have the board members determine that the client did not do what he/she is accused of doing.  In other words, there is no basis for discharge and the respondent must be retained in the military. 

CASE #1

In the first administrative discharge board case, which was a Board of Inquiry (BOI), the military officer was accused of sexual assault (UCMJ Article 120).  Therefore, this litigated hearing was very similar to a military sexual assault court-martial trial.  After fully litigating this hearing, and making closing arguments in the hearing, the board members determined that the military officer did not commit sexual assault.  They found there was no basis for discharge, and the military officer must be retained in the service. 

CASE #2

In the second administrative discharge board case, which was also a Board of Inquiry (BOI), the military officer was accused of violating military standards.  After fully litigating this hearing, and making closing arguments in the hearing, the board members determined that the military officer did not violate military standards.  They found there was no basis for discharge, and the military officer must be retained in the service. 

Because these were administrative cases, more details cannot be provided.  While these involuntary administrative discharge board cases were successfully defended, and the clients were retained in the military, it is important to understand that every case has different facts, and success in previous cases does not guarantee success in any particular future case.  No military lawyer or civilian defense lawyer, including those who specialize in military law, can guarantee the outcome of any military trial or case. 

For more information about the military justice system, particularly cases involving administrative discharge actions, see:

https://militaryadvocate.com/practice-areas/administrative-discharge-separation/

We offer free consultations for a case you may be involved in.  Just call us. 

Thank you. 

Military Defense Law Offices of Richard V. Stevens, P.C.

Civilian Criminal Defense Lawyer and Military Defense Lawyer

https://militaryadvocate.com/

Blog postscript: I (attorney Richard V. Stevens) am a former active duty military lawyer (JAG). My perspectives and advice, therefore, are based upon my experience as military defense lawyer and as a civilian criminal defense lawyer practicing exclusively in the area of military law and military justice. This blog addresses issues in military law, military justice, military discipline, military defense, court-martial practice, the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ) and other military and/or legal topics. Nothing posted in this blog should be substituted for legal advice in any particular case. If you seek legal advice for a particular case, please contact The Law Offices of Richard V. Stevens for a free consultation. These military defense law offices are located in the Washington DC, Northern Virginia, Maryland, National Capital Region (NCR), but the military defense representation is worldwide – when necessary, the attorneys travel to wherever the client is stationed around the world.


No comments: